Discussion, why did the Cold War end?

 

There are two different models / ways used to explain the end of the cold war. The first way of explaining states that it was the failures within in the communist societies that led to the fall of Communism, this fall then led to the end of Cold War. The second way of explaining what happens states that it was a logic consequence of the external factors, the detente had set off a chain of events that eventually would lead to the end of the Cold War.

 

Internal explanation.

 

Once Poland had succeeded in having free elections without the interference of the soviet Army the citizens of other countries dared to make their voices heard. When Hungary opened it’s borders to Austria a hole in the Iron curtain was opened leading to thousands of East Germans taking their Trabants and went to West Germany.

These two events set off a chain reaction that would lead to the fall off communism. Without the threat of the Red Army, the local communist parties simply couldn’t maintain their authority and like a house of cards the communist regimes in Europe would fall.

 

External explanation.

 

The Détente had started something that couldn’t be stopped, it was impossible to go from cooperation to confrontation, once the superpower had started the way down the friendship lane, there was no turning back. Gorbachev has to be seen out this perspective, he the kind of leader the was destined to come, the actual time for his arrival was a chance, but that a new kind of leader was needed was apparent.

Gorbachev and his “Sinatra Doctrine” was the single most important factor that lead to the fall of communism and hence the end of the cold war.

Reagan and his SDI meant that USSR had no chance of keeping up with USA and had to start cooperating.

The politics of these two leaders are very important in this explanation.

Another external factor used to explain that the Cold War ended is the fact that there were no more things to fight about, Europe had reached a status quo since the beginning of the Ostpolitik and had only became hotter for a short while at the beginning of the 80’s and the SS20 / Pershing problems. Once the issue was settled, there were no more arenas to fight on, the Soviet adventures in the third world had come to shame after the invasion of Afghanistan etc. This in combination with the growing economic problems that USSR had with the satelitte states meant that the Cold War would eventually end.

 

Questions:

 

  1. What historical facts support the internal explanation?
  2. What historical facts contradict the internal explanation?
  3. What historical facts support the external explanation?
  4. What historical facts contradict the external explanation?
  5. Make a timeline of the events from 1989 – 2001 and the dismantling of USSR. Focus on key events and international agreements made between USSR and USA.
  6. Why, in your opinion was the Wall opened on the evening of November 9 1989? Make notes so you can participate in the discussion later on. Use the answers from above.